VPNs · updated 2026-11-19

Best VPN services, ranked by real users

We scored 9 VPN services using 1,645 Reddit comments where users rate a service they use, from r/ProtonVPN, r/mullvadvpn, r/nordvpn, r/surfshark, r/PrivateInternetAccess and others. Surfshark ranks first. Prices were checked on each provider's own pricing page on 2026-11-03.

Compare VPN prices · Methodology

1

Surfshark

222 rated user comments · from $2.49/mo
Praised for apps & devices · Complaints about apps & devices
4.0
2

AirVPN

13 rated user comments
Praised for torrenting
3.9
3

Proton VPN

329 rated user comments · from $3.49/mo
Praised for apps & devices · Complaints about apps & devices
3.8
4

Private Internet Access (PIA)

192 rated user comments · from $2.03/mo
Praised for apps & devices · Complaints about apps & devices
3.7
5

NordVPN

386 rated user comments · from $3.49/mo
Praised for apps & devices · Complaints about apps & devices
3.6
6

Mullvad VPN

445 rated user comments · from $5.62/mo
Praised for apps & devices · Complaints about apps & devices
3.4
7

ExpressVPN

17 rated user comments · from $3.00/mo
Praised for reliability · Complaints about apps & devices
3.2
8

Windscribe

26 rated user comments · from $5.75/mo
Praised for security & privacy · Complaints about speed
3.0
9

IVPN

7 rated user comments
Praised for security & privacy · Complaints about security & privacy
3.0

Score breakdown

VPNOverallUser sentimentRecommendationsTrouble-freeValueRated comments
Surfshark4.03.15.04.34.7222
AirVPN3.93.92.55.0Not rated13
Proton VPN3.83.14.84.33.6329
Private Internet Access (PIA)3.73.22.54.35.0192
NordVPN3.63.14.04.33.6386
Mullvad VPN3.43.24.84.71.1445
ExpressVPN3.22.81.04.54.117
Windscribe3.03.71.04.91.026
IVPN3.03.01.04.3Not rated7

Best value score: Private Internet Access (PIA) (5.0/5), based on its entry price relative to the other VPN services.

What users talk about

Apps & devices · 476Speed · 257Reliability · 247Security & privacy · 162Customer support · 117Streaming · 101

Best VPN for…

Best VPN for streaming

5 VPN services compared on 96 user comments about streaming

Best VPN for torrenting

7 VPN services compared on 98 user comments about torrenting

Best VPN for privacy

8 VPN services compared on 162 user comments about security & privacy

Best budget VPN

6 VPN services compared on 55 user comments about value for money

Fastest VPN (owner reports)

8 VPN services compared on 255 user comments about speed

Head-to-head comparisons

AirVPN vs IVPNMullvad VPN vs AirVPNPrivate Internet Access (PIA) vs AirVPNProton VPN vs AirVPNWindscribe vs AirVPNMullvad VPN vs ExpressVPNNordVPN vs ExpressVPNPrivate Internet Access (PIA) vs ExpressVPNProton VPN vs ExpressVPNSurfshark vs ExpressVPNWindscribe vs ExpressVPNMullvad VPN vs IVPNProton VPN vs IVPNWindscribe vs IVPNMullvad VPN vs NordVPNMullvad VPN vs Private Internet Access (PIA)Mullvad VPN vs Proton VPNMullvad VPN vs SurfsharkMullvad VPN vs WindscribeNordVPN vs Private Internet Access (PIA)NordVPN vs Proton VPNNordVPN vs SurfsharkNordVPN vs WindscribeProton VPN vs Private Internet Access (PIA)Surfshark vs Private Internet Access (PIA)Private Internet Access (PIA) vs WindscribeProton VPN vs SurfsharkProton VPN vs WindscribeSurfshark vs Windscribe

Also mentioned (limited data)

These came up in fewer than 5 rated user comments, so we do not rank them. Their pages show the evidence we have.

IPVanish (4)CyberGhost (4)

FAQ

What is the best VPN according to Reddit users?

Surfshark has the highest overall score (4.0/5) among the 9 VPN services with at least 5 rated user comments in our sample of Reddit comments from 2025-11-01 to 2026-11-01.

Which VPN do users rate most positively?

AirVPN has the highest user sentiment score (3.9/5, from 13 rated comments). Sentiment is weighted for upvotes and recency and pulled toward the category average when there are few comments.

What is the cheapest VPN?

Of the ranked VPN services, Private Internet Access (PIA) has the lowest advertised entry price we saw: $2.03/mo (3-year plan, autorenews at $81.20 every 3 years), checked on 2026-11-03 on its own pricing page. It renews at $81.20 every 3 years.

What do users complain about most with VPN services?

The most-discussed topics across the category are apps & devices (476 mentions), speed (257 mentions), reliability (247 mentions).