How we score services
Every score on eServices comes from one formula applied to public Reddit comments and to prices on each provider's own pricing page. We do not test services ourselves, accept payment for placement, or write reviews of our own. The quotes are Reddit user comments; we link each one to the original.
1. Collecting comments
We pulled public comments posted between 2025-11-01 and 2026-11-01 from the Arctic Shift Reddit archive. Smaller subreddits (for example a provider's own subreddit) were read in full for every month; large general subreddits were sampled by taking the first few days of each month, so every month of the year is represented. In total we scanned 833,262 comments from 38 subreddits with ranked data, including r/ProtonVPN, r/mullvadvpn, r/nordvpn, r/surfshark, r/PrivateInternetAccess, r/VPN, r/selfhosted, r/Bitwarden, r/Hosting, r/webhosting, r/WordPress, r/web_design.
2. Finding real users
- A comment counts only if it names a provider and reads as first-hand use ("I've used…", "my account…", "we switched to…"). Questions, news reposts and "has anyone tried" comments do not count.
- Bots, deleted comments, and referral or affiliate-code pitches are excluded (1165 referral mentions removed).
- Coordinated text (the same opening posted by 3 or more accounts) is excluded as likely marketing (110 mentions removed).
- A comment that says a user switched from one service to another counts as a low rating (2/5) for the old one and a good rating (4/5) for the new one.
- Each comment is rated 1–5 from its wording and tagged with topics such as support, reliability, billing or speed. This is automated and imperfect; that is why every quote links to the original.
Result: 109,969 provider mentions, 23,488 first-hand user comments, 10,284 with a usable rating.
3. The score
The overall score (1–5) is a weighted blend of four components:
| Component | Weight | What it measures |
|---|---|---|
| User sentiment | 40% | Average rating of first-hand comments, weighted by upvotes (log scale) and doubled for the last 12 months, then pulled toward the category average with a prior worth 5 comments: (5 × category mean + Σ weight × rating) / (5 + Σ weight). A service with few comments cannot get an extreme score. |
| Recommendations | 15% | How often users actively recommend it ("go with X", "I'd recommend X"), relative to the category, on a 1–5 scale. Not rated when nobody recommends it explicitly. |
| Trouble-free reports | 25% | Share of rated comments that do not complain about reliability, support, billing/cancellation or price rises, smoothed the same way: 1 + 4 × share. |
| Value (entry price) | 20% | Entry price from the provider's pricing page compared with the rest of the category: within 10% of the cheapest paid price scores 5, the most expensive scores 1, linear in between. Not rated when we could not read a price. |
If a component is Not rated, its weight is shared among the others. Services with fewer than 5 rated user comments get a page marked "limited data", are not ranked, and are hidden from search engines.
4. Prices
Prices were read on 2026-11-03 from each provider's own pricing page and are shown with that date. Where a page renders prices with JavaScript or blocks automated reads, we read the official page through a search index and mark it with an asterisk. We never use prices from third-party sites. Prices change often; always confirm on the provider's site before buying.
5. Limits
- Reddit users are not a random sample: unhappy customers post more, and provider subreddits skew toward existing customers.
- The rating classifier reads text automatically and will misread some sarcasm and mixed comments.
- We do not measure speed, uptime or security ourselves.
- Categories we planned but did not publish because the Reddit evidence was too thin: E-signature.
Money: see our affiliate disclosure. Commissions never change a score; the formula has no input for them.