VPNs · updated 2026-11-19

Best VPN for privacy

This ranks VPN services only on what users say about security & privacy: 162 rated comments that discuss it. The theme rating is a weighted average of those comments, pulled toward the middle when a service has few. A service's overall score is shown for context.

#VPNSecurity & privacy ratingComments on thisPositiveOverall score
1Windscribe3.8443.0
2Surfshark3.51284.0
3Mullvad VPN3.371403.4
4Private Internet Access (PIA)3.21773.7
5Proton VPN3.125123.8
6IVPN3.0323.0
7NordVPN2.92893.6
8ExpressVPN2.5203.2

1. Windscribe

Windscribe has 4 rated comments about security & privacy, 4 of them positive, for a security & privacy rating of 3.8/5.

“I will say Windscribe gets clobbered by cloudfare sites more than the other two for me, but is generally better for stream region hopping.”
· user comment via r/ProtonVPN · 2026-10-30Security & privacy
“As I said Mullvad deprecated port forwarding feature, you better look at other alternatives, like Proton or Windscribe.”
· user comment via r/mullvadvpn · 2025-11-29Security & privacyTorrenting

Full Windscribe review · Visit Windscribe

2. Surfshark

Surfshark has 12 rated comments about security & privacy, 8 of them positive, for a security & privacy rating of 3.5/5.

“Some people using surfshark have no issues.”
· user comment via r/surfshark · 2026-08-27Security & privacy
“We're always looking for ways to improve Surfshark, whether that's tweaking the UI, phasing out features people don't really use, or making the tools people rely on every day even better.”
· user comment via r/surfshark · 2026-07-31Ease of useSecurity & privacy

Full Surfshark review · Visit Surfshark

3. Mullvad VPN

Mullvad VPN has 71 rated comments about security & privacy, 40 of them positive, for a security & privacy rating of 3.3/5.

“For me there's only 2 good VPNs, proton and Mullvad (when it comes to the highest privacy standards)”
· user comment via r/ProtonVPN · 2026-10-30Security & privacy
“This is also pretty much what Mullvad used to implement their QUIC obfuscation layer.”
· user comment via r/mullvadvpn · 2026-07-02Security & privacyCustomer support

Full Mullvad VPN review · Visit Mullvad VPN

4. Private Internet Access (PIA)

Private Internet Access (PIA) has 17 rated comments about security & privacy, 7 of them positive, for a security & privacy rating of 3.2/5.

“I've used private internet access since about 2011 and I have never had a problem.”
· user comment via r/PrivateInternetAccess · 2026-03-03ReliabilitySecurity & privacy
“Even if you turn the pia vpn off, changing the DNS settings won't do you much good privacy wise.”
· user comment via r/PrivateInternetAccess · 2026-04-11Security & privacySpeed

Full Private Internet Access (PIA) review · Visit Private Internet Access (PIA)

5. Proton VPN

Proton VPN has 25 rated comments about security & privacy, 12 of them positive, for a security & privacy rating of 3.1/5.

“We therefore strongly recommend against using DoH (and the similar DNS over TLS standard) with Proton VPN”
· user comment via r/ProtonVPN · 2026-07-16Security & privacyCustomer support
“I use ControlD with my ProtonVPN. Benefits are better control and privacy, I can use whatever popular filters I want and make my own rules. Example I block all domains in China, Google, Facebook etc.”
· user comment via r/ProtonVPN · 2026-08-19Security & privacy

Full Proton VPN review · Visit Proton VPN

6. IVPN

IVPN has 3 rated comments about security & privacy, 2 of them positive, for a security & privacy rating of 3.0/5.

“I've used IVPN, AirVPN, Windscribe, Proton, Nym, and Hide.me, so I think I can offer some valuable insight.”
· user comment via r/mullvadvpn · 2026-08-17Security & privacy
“It's one of the most transparent vpn companies honestly I would only use mullvad proton or ivpn if privacy is a concern all of their apps and browser extensions are really great free is great for privacy and paid is also great if you want…”
· user comment via r/ProtonVPN · 2026-01-11Apps & devicesSecurity & privacy

Full IVPN review · Visit IVPN

7. NordVPN

NordVPN has 28 rated comments about security & privacy, 9 of them positive, for a security & privacy rating of 2.9/5.

“I use NordVPN more for the encryption and its security features than for total anonymity, some of the sites am signed into while using.”
· user comment via r/nordvpn · 2026-02-25Apps & devicesSecurity & privacy
“Tonight, on the new TV, I tried probably 5–10 different NordVPN servers and couldn’t get MLB.TV to work at all.”
· user comment via r/nordvpn · 2026-06-07Security & privacy

Full NordVPN review · Visit NordVPN

8. ExpressVPN

ExpressVPN has 2 rated comments about security & privacy, 0 of them positive, for a security & privacy rating of 2.5/5.

Full ExpressVPN review · Visit ExpressVPN

Provider links are sponsored. Disclosure · Methodology