VPNs · updated 2026-11-19

Best budget VPN

This ranks VPN services only on what users say about value for money: 55 rated comments that discuss it. The theme rating is a weighted average of those comments, pulled toward the middle when a service has few. A service's overall score is shown for context.

#VPNValue for money ratingComments on thisPositiveOverall score
1Windscribe3.9223.0
2NordVPN3.71083.6
3Surfshark3.71074.0
4Mullvad VPN3.615103.4
5Private Internet Access (PIA)3.6963.7
6Proton VPN3.5963.8

1. Windscribe

Windscribe has 2 rated comments about value for money, 2 of them positive, for a value for money rating of 3.9/5.

“I use Windscribe, it's cheaper than mullvad or proton and I consider it to be very good!”
· user comment via r/mullvadvpn · 2026-10-28Value for money
“I’ve been with Windscribe for several years now.”
· user comment via r/VPN · 2026-05-20Value for money

Full Windscribe review · Visit Windscribe

2. NordVPN

NordVPN has 10 rated comments about value for money, 8 of them positive, for a value for money rating of 3.7/5.

“Proton has been the most consistent for me as well, Nord can be cheaper but proton has given me 100% of my speed every time almost when it fluctuates more often with Nord”
· user comment via r/ProtonVPN · 2026-09-09SpeedValue for money
“Amazon has 1 year for $29.99, and NordVPN allows stacking.”
· user comment via r/nordvpn · 2026-04-08Value for money

Full NordVPN review · Visit NordVPN

3. Surfshark

Surfshark has 10 rated comments about value for money, 7 of them positive, for a value for money rating of 3.7/5.

“Only reason i stayed was a cheap renewal and Surfshark does get decent speed with torrenting compared to Proton that i briefly tried.”
· user comment via r/surfshark · 2026-10-11ReliabilitySpeed
“I still use Surfshark because it's cheaper.”
· user comment via r/ProtonVPN · 2026-07-14Value for money

Full Surfshark review · Visit Surfshark

4. Mullvad VPN

Mullvad VPN has 15 rated comments about value for money, 10 of them positive, for a value for money rating of 3.6/5.

“But since Proton is cheaper for the first year or two if you buy two years up front, you could use proton then switch to Mullvad when the price goes up.”
· user comment via r/mullvadvpn · 2026-10-28ReliabilityValue for money
“I'd suggest getting a cheap VPS outside of China, running Mullvad VPN on that, and just connect to the VPS through HAproxy with V2Ray .”
· user comment via r/mullvadvpn · 2025-11-24Value for money

Full Mullvad VPN review · Visit Mullvad VPN

5. Private Internet Access (PIA)

Private Internet Access (PIA) has 9 rated comments about value for money, 6 of them positive, for a value for money rating of 3.6/5.

“Quick workaround: shove Dante on a cheap VPS, pipe it through your PIA tunnel, then point your app at that VPS instead of the flaky IP list.”
· user comment via r/PrivateInternetAccess · 2025-12-01Apps & devicesStreaming
“PIA is actually one of the cheaper ones.”
· user comment via r/PrivateInternetAccess · 2026-01-01ReliabilityValue for money

Full Private Internet Access (PIA) review · Visit Private Internet Access (PIA)

6. Proton VPN

Proton VPN has 9 rated comments about value for money, 6 of them positive, for a value for money rating of 3.5/5.

“What this did was delete my cheaper ProtonVPN subscription and give me JUST Proton Pass.”
· user comment via r/1Password · 2026-03-02Value for money
“i've been using free proton vpn for the past two months or so and it has been rock solid the whole time.”
· user comment via r/ProtonVPN · 2026-07-02ReliabilitySpeed

Full Proton VPN review · Visit Proton VPN

Provider links are sponsored. Disclosure · Methodology