VPNs comparison · updated 2026-11-19

Surfshark vs Windscribe

Surfshark scores 4.0/5 against Windscribe's 3.0/5, from 222 and 26 rated user comments respectively. Surfshark leads on recommendations, value (entry price). Windscribe leads on user sentiment, trouble-free reports. 10 comments in our sample mention both.

SurfsharkWindscribe
Overall score4.03.0
User sentiment3.13.7
Recommendations5.01.0
Trouble-free reports4.34.9
Value (entry price)4.71.0
Rated user comments22226
Rank in VPN services#1 of 11#10 of 11
Entry price (2026-11-03)$2.49/mo$5.75/mo
Renews at—$69/year
Month-to-month—$9.00/mo
Most praisedApps & devicesSecurity & privacy
Top complaintApps & devicesSpeed

Topics both get discussed for

TopicSurfshark mentionsWindscribe mentions
Apps & devices772
Speed382
Reliability231
Billing & cancelling161
Security & privacy124

What users say about Surfshark

“Some people using surfshark have no issues.”
· user comment via r/surfshark · 2026-08-27Security & privacy
“All these reports is why I’ve stopped using Surfshark.”

Full Surfshark review

Visit Surfshark

What users say about Windscribe

“Check out windscribe, I moved from another big vpn provider and windscribe has been great so far”
“Now I'm using windscribe which has port forwarding and all servers are literally physically my speed is faster with windscribe I have no regrets and the price ain't bad it kills the premium competitors.”
· user comment via r/ProtonVPN · 2025-12-17SpeedTorrenting

Full Windscribe review

Visit Windscribe

Provider links are sponsored. Disclosure · Methodology

FAQ

Is Surfshark or Windscribe better?

Surfshark scores 4.0/5 against Windscribe's 3.0/5, from 222 and 26 rated user comments respectively. Surfshark leads on recommendations, value (entry price). Windscribe leads on user sentiment, trouble-free reports.

Which is cheaper, Surfshark or Windscribe?

Advertised entry prices on 2026-11-03: Surfshark $2.49/mo, Windscribe $5.75/mo. Check renewal prices, which are often higher.

All VPN services ranked