VPNs comparison · updated 2026-11-19

Proton VPN vs Private Internet Access (PIA)

Proton VPN scores 3.8/5 against Private Internet Access (PIA)'s 3.7/5, from 329 and 192 rated user comments respectively. Proton VPN leads on recommendations, trouble-free reports. Private Internet Access (PIA) leads on user sentiment, value (entry price). 30 comments in our sample mention both.

Proton VPNPrivate Internet Access (PIA)
Overall score3.83.7
User sentiment3.13.2
Recommendations4.82.5
Trouble-free reports4.34.3
Value (entry price)3.65.0
Rated user comments329192
Rank in VPN services#3 of 11#4 of 11
Entry price (2026-11-03)$3.49/mo$2.03/mo
Renews at—$81.20 every 3 years
Month-to-month$9.99/mo$11.95/mo
Most praisedApps & devicesApps & devices
Top complaintApps & devicesApps & devices

Topics both get discussed for

TopicProton VPN mentionsPrivate Internet Access (PIA) mentions
Apps & devices12248
Reliability6840
Speed3944
Security & privacy2517
Customer support2414

What users say about Proton VPN

“ProtonVPN's free option (which also comes with a free email address, or vice versa) is generous in terms of data usage each month.”
“And I say that *knowing* that ProtonVPN is SO SO SO close to being an excellent product.”
· user comment via r/ProtonVPN · 2026-06-14Apps & devices

Full Proton VPN review

Visit Proton VPN

What users say about Private Internet Access (PIA)

“I just renewed Pia for another 3 years,used it the last four years,no complaints.”
“breaking something as important as port forwarding without a clear announcement is gonna upset the people who specifically chose PIA because it supported that feature.”
· user comment via r/PrivateInternetAccess · 2026-06-09Torrenting

Full Private Internet Access (PIA) review

Visit Private Internet Access (PIA)

Provider links are sponsored. Disclosure · Methodology

FAQ

Is Proton VPN or Private Internet Access (PIA) better?

Proton VPN scores 3.8/5 against Private Internet Access (PIA)'s 3.7/5, from 329 and 192 rated user comments respectively. Proton VPN leads on recommendations, trouble-free reports. Private Internet Access (PIA) leads on user sentiment, value (entry price).

Which is cheaper, Proton VPN or Private Internet Access (PIA)?

Advertised entry prices on 2026-11-03: Proton VPN $3.49/mo, Private Internet Access (PIA) $2.03/mo. Check renewal prices, which are often higher.

All VPN services ranked