VPNs comparison · updated 2026-11-19

Surfshark vs Private Internet Access (PIA)

Surfshark scores 4.0/5 against Private Internet Access (PIA)'s 3.7/5, from 222 and 192 rated user comments respectively. Surfshark leads on recommendations, trouble-free reports. Private Internet Access (PIA) leads on user sentiment, value (entry price). 26 comments in our sample mention both.

SurfsharkPrivate Internet Access (PIA)
Overall score4.03.7
User sentiment3.13.2
Recommendations5.02.5
Trouble-free reports4.34.3
Value (entry price)4.75.0
Rated user comments222192
Rank in VPN services#1 of 11#4 of 11
Entry price (2026-11-03)$2.49/mo$2.03/mo
Renews at—$81.20 every 3 years
Month-to-month—$11.95/mo
Most praisedApps & devicesApps & devices
Top complaintApps & devicesApps & devices

Topics both get discussed for

TopicSurfshark mentionsPrivate Internet Access (PIA) mentions
Apps & devices7748
Speed3844
Customer support3214
Reliability2340
Billing & cancelling169

What users say about Surfshark

“Some people using surfshark have no issues.”
· user comment via r/surfshark · 2026-08-27Security & privacy
“All these reports is why I’ve stopped using Surfshark.”

Full Surfshark review

Visit Surfshark

What users say about Private Internet Access (PIA)

“I just renewed Pia for another 3 years,used it the last four years,no complaints.”
“breaking something as important as port forwarding without a clear announcement is gonna upset the people who specifically chose PIA because it supported that feature.”
· user comment via r/PrivateInternetAccess · 2026-06-09Torrenting

Full Private Internet Access (PIA) review

Visit Private Internet Access (PIA)

Provider links are sponsored. Disclosure · Methodology

FAQ

Is Surfshark or Private Internet Access (PIA) better?

Surfshark scores 4.0/5 against Private Internet Access (PIA)'s 3.7/5, from 222 and 192 rated user comments respectively. Surfshark leads on recommendations, trouble-free reports. Private Internet Access (PIA) leads on user sentiment, value (entry price).

Which is cheaper, Surfshark or Private Internet Access (PIA)?

Advertised entry prices on 2026-11-03: Surfshark $2.49/mo, Private Internet Access (PIA) $2.03/mo. Check renewal prices, which are often higher.

All VPN services ranked