Password managers comparison · updated 2026-11-19

1Password vs Proton Pass

Proton Pass scores 3.6/5 against 1Password's 3.4/5, from 285 and 851 rated user comments respectively. 1Password leads on recommendations. Proton Pass leads on user sentiment, trouble-free reports. 542 comments in our sample mention both.

1PasswordProton Pass
Overall score3.43.6
User sentiment3.23.6
Recommendations4.03.7
Trouble-free reports4.34.7
Value (entry price)2.32.3
Rated user comments851285
Rank in password managers#7 of 10#5 of 10
Entry price (2026-11-03)$2.99/mo$2.99/mo
Renews at$3.99/mo billed annually—
Month-to-month—$4.99/mo
Most praisedSecurity & privacyEase of use
Top complaintSecurity & privacyBilling & cancelling

Topics both get discussed for

Topic1Password mentionsProton Pass mentions
Security & privacy14219
Autofill11933
Family sharing9710
Customer support8711
Passkeys & 2FA7324

What users say about 1Password

“I love 1Password as well (been a user since like 2009) but when they are advertising on F1 cars and then raise the price I get annoyed.”
“I'm 90% sure turning off Live Text has solved problems with 1Password, Grammarly, and RAM usage for me.”
· user comment via r/1Password · 2025-11-24Autofill

Full 1Password review

Visit 1Password

What users say about Proton Pass

“Better mobile app - Adds recommendations to spotlight search on iOS, inbuilt password sharing, better UI, shows accounts with 2FA not setup (with Proton Pass) and weak / duplicate passwords.”
· user comment via r/PasswordManagers · 2026-10-06AutofillEase of use
“I migrated two days ago to Proton Pass and my colleague told me about reversing the price hike.”
· user comment via r/PasswordManagers · 2026-03-04Renewal prices & upsells

Full Proton Pass review

Visit Proton Pass

Provider links are sponsored. Disclosure · Methodology

FAQ

Is 1Password or Proton Pass better?

Proton Pass scores 3.6/5 against 1Password's 3.4/5, from 285 and 851 rated user comments respectively. 1Password leads on recommendations. Proton Pass leads on user sentiment, trouble-free reports.

Which is cheaper, 1Password or Proton Pass?

Advertised entry prices on 2026-11-03: 1Password $2.99/mo, Proton Pass $2.99/mo. Check renewal prices, which are often higher.

All password managers ranked